Entrepreneurship-Driven Innovation as a Growth Driver for Greece’s Economy

A couple of days ago I delivered a speech during the inauguration ceremonies of the Alexandrian Innovation Zone, in Thessaloniki, Greece.  This zone is supposed to become the beginning of a Silicon Valley-like area in Greece and provide a venue for economic growth in the country.  I thought that it would be worthwhile to post a few excerpts from the speech, particularly in order to elicit feedback on the immediate steps I proposed for Greece to take to increase the probability of this initiative’s success.

Greece recognizes that entrepreneurship-driven innovation is a major driver in modern economies.  The importance of innovation-driven economies and the emulation of Silicon Valley’s successful model in creating such economies have been recognized as early as the 80s by Israel (see here for an overview) but later on by several other countries, and most recently by Russia, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan.  All these countries are trying to learn from Silicon Valley’s successes and failures, identify their regional advantages, and then adapt Silicon Valley’s model to enhance these advantages.  First, it is important to stress that Silicon Valley was created over a period of 50 years.  So any such initiative must be given the time to flourish and must become a national goal.  Second, one should be careful to properly adapt the Silicon Valley’s model to the region’s characteristics.  By drawing lessons from Silicon Valley and other similar efforts and tailoring them appropriately to Greece’s innovation model and Thessaloniki’s regional characteristics, Greece can make the Alexandrian Innovation Zone succeed and broaden its impact to its constituents and beyond.

...

I would like to now propose a few make easy steps that Greece will need to consider taking around the Alexandrian Innovation Zone.  Initially I propose that Greece applies these steps around only to the high-tech sector.  The goal would be to create some quick successes that can be used as a springboard for additional more fundamental and broader changes.

1.       Make easy and inexpensive the creation, financing and dissolution of high tech companies.  Starting up a business and getting the proper regulatory permits should be quick, and inexpensive; not rocket science.  Look at the examples of countries like Singapore where it is possible for a company to be established and funded within weeks.  Moreover make easy for small companies to obtain lines of credit from local or foreign banks so that they will have appropriate working capital.  Offer incentives to the banks to provide such loans.  Look at banks like the Silicon Valley Bank that specialize in this area.

2.       Teach entrepreneurs that from the beginning of their venture they must consider the world markets for their products rather than the Greek market alone and make that easy.  We all understand that the Greek market is small.  In this respect it is not dissimilar from the Irish, Israeli and Singaporean markets.  In these countries new companies learn to develop products with global appeal and start marketing them internationally very early on in the product development cycle.

3.       Make it easy to captivate the local talent as well as attract the best people possible from around the world for the technology sectors being pursued and the companies being formed.  Understand that Silicon Valley is not about the people who live here, it’s about the people who are attracted here. China, and India but also Singapore and Saudi Arabia are doing exactly that.  It is not important to only have the right technology innovators but you need to staff companies with people from other disciplines to make them successful.  Product managers who shape the product to address the market’s needs, engineering executives who lead the teams that transform an innovative technology to a product the market can use, sales and marketing executives who propel the product to the international markets, and CEOs that lead the companies to great outcomes must be part of any such effort.

4.       Establish intellectual-property offices in the country’s main universities and make easy and fast the spinning out of research from universities and national labs.  Negotiation of IP rights and licensing of patents should be done in weeks not months or years.  Make easy for professors and students to leave the university to start a company and then return back to the university.  The constant flow between academia and industry has been rejuvenating for many academics in the US, Israel, India, Brazil and Singapore. 

5.       Make easy the importation and exportation of foreign capital.  Learn from Israel, India, China and Russia, on how their governments continue to work with American venture capital firms to establish ways to start new investment funds in these countries and jump start their innovation-driven economies.  

6.       Make it easy for high tech startups to operate by offering to lower their taxes, and collect these taxes only after the startup’s losses are recouped and offer an additional tax-free period of a few years during which the company is profitable.

7.       Make easy the provisioning of infrastructure, from signing office space leases, to getting various permits, telephone lines and broadband internet.  Learn from best practices in Singapore, and Silicon Valley.

These are some of the short-term steps that you should consider.  These are some of the short-term steps that you should consider.  For the medium term you should consider providing a more growth-friendly corporate tax environment, as well as other incentives that will cause particularly large foreign high tech companies to come and establish technology operations in Greece, and making easy for entrepreneurs of failed companies to start new ventures.  Longer term you will need to work on providing a transparent financing environment, an area we are now advising Russia on, creating special incentives to attract larger pools of risk capital and making corporate M&A easy.

You will know that your initial steps are having the right impact when the pace of high tech company creation increases, the products of the financed companies start to attract the attention of the international markets, and capital begins to flow into Greece to be invested in these companies.

…

This will be a multi year, national, and difficult effort that must involve a unique partnership between government, academia, industry and people.  In order to succeed, Greece will need to execute flawlessly and consistently while competing successfully at the international stage.

…

I look forward to your comments on the above and additional suggestions for steps that will be important for countries like Greece to take in order to spur entrepreneurship-driven innovation and economic growth.

Comments

[Sotiris Karagiannis]

Dear Evangele,

I can't believe I missed your speech!!
I live 10Km from the Zone and I would certainly have attented just to listen to
your speech and even have a chat with you :)

Unfortunatelly I didn't see a twitter post about your visit. Have you already left Greece?

Anyway, all the above points are mostly correct. Specially the point for the Greek enterpreneurs looking at a Global market and
not Greece.

If you have had the time to visit places around the Zone, you could have seen that a lot of companies in incubator schemes are not proposing something that could really make an investors eyes to open wide.

Most of them are in need of an office space and some basic services of an incubator. But trully, i wouldn't invest
my money in any of them (with an exception of one or at most two and not for the global market).

This is not me being negative. This is being realistic. The business environment in Greece is ill. Government policies are changing every year, in a largely unstable
and unsure way of collecting taxes.

There is no true differentiation between innovation and generic business. At least in real life (cause politicians always claim that everything is roses).

If you come and live in Greece for sometime,
you will also notice that Thessaloniki is remembered every September. You know why.
Because of the Fair. :)

There is a joke in Greek that says "its another thing to be PANIGIRIKOS and another thing to be PANIGIRI". This is what happens every Semptember here. We all wait for the active Prime Minister to come to Thessaloniki and promise that Innovation is the future and the Government will do what ever it can to promote it. I was young and reached mid forties and the situations has changed only be an inch (imoun nios kai gerasa :)

So, IMHO, if one would like the Alexandrian Zone to become a success, he should first establish a Solid Management scheme with sucessfull business people - even VC experts - in the top, give them FULL POWER, even more than a minister's power, pass laws and let them make all promises true in all points you mentioned above.

Of course, I could be just ignorant and not able to see something that already exists or is planned seriously this time by our
new government. (PS I only trust GAP as one
person that would push things a bit, but
am still afraid that the system around him
is happy enough with the media coverage).

Please, if you know the opposite, share it with us.

(if you are still around, i would greatly value a chat and a greek coffee to go with it ..)

Regards

[Evangelos]

Thank you very much for your comments and observations.

I gave my speech via video conference which was an interesting experience in itself given the size of the audience (over 250 as I understand). I hope to be able to stay close to the Zone's developments.

Many of these projects around the world have stagnated but given the level of entrepreneurship in Greece I think that the raw ingredients are there for a success. We will have to see whether the announcements and speeches are followed by a solid action plan. As I indicated in my speech, Greece will need to execute flawlessly and over a long period of time for this initiative to succeed. This has to be a national initiative behind which Greeks of every political orientation have to line up. Otherwise, it will become another while elephant.

[Sotiris Karagiannis]

Thank you Evangele,

The Zone indeed has a chance, being in the heart of the Balkans and with a great future if the plan starts up.
I completely agree with the National plan and be sure that every entrepreneur does not care about politics. He envisions the future and cares mainly about the opportunity and expects from his government to just give him the chance to excel.
This is what the US has given to the world of innovation : simply the chance to excel.

By the way, is your speech in any way recorded or published anywhere as a video?

Regards

Sotiris

[Eleni]

Your speech is very insightful and accurately depicts the obstacles for growth in Greece.

[Angelos Karageorgiou]

Modern economies are based on IT innovation. Unfortunately Greece is by default averse to IT and/or innovation, a look into the political establishment which is the cornerstone of Greek mentality will prove my point.

Best of luck , from one who should have never returned home.